The Effective and Ethical Use of AI in Investments

Navigating a new frontier while shaping the future Tianyang Wang
Photo: Getty Images/piranka

The transformative potential artificial intelligence (AI) and large language models (LLMs) offer in reshaping traditional financial practices serves as motivation for exploring their potential impacts on the investment sector. As AI continues to evolve rapidly, equally expansive tools provide unprecedented opportunities to enhance the analytical capabilities of investment professionals. This evolution significantly shifts the way data is processed and analyzed, allowing for more efficient handling of vast datasets and the identification of complex patterns that typically could elude human analysis.1 Using AI in investments unlocks a number of potential opportunities and challenges for actuaries as we navigate this new frontier.

AI and LLMs in the Investment Sector

This article revolves around the immediate utility and potential long-term implications of AI and LLMs in various facets of the investment process. These technologies have been instrumental in augmenting operational efficiency through advancements in investment analysis, risk assessment, financial forecasting and personalized client advisory services.2 Integration within the investment sector necessitates a careful balance. While AI and LLMs bring efficiency and enhanced analytical capabilities, it is imperative to maintain synergy with the human expertise that remains critical for strategic decision-making.

From my academic perspective, the need to adapt college and university educational curricula to include AI and LLMs has become increasingly apparent. I believe that by weaving AI, machine learning and data analytics into finance and investment programs, educational institutions could prepare a new generation of investment professionals capable of navigating the complexities of a technology-driven market. As these technologies cement their role in the investment landscape, the demand for professionals who are not only adept in traditional investment strategies but also proficient in utilizing AI for data-driven decision-making will escalate.

Moreover, as we harness the capabilities of AI and LLMs, I believe it’s crucial to integrate education on ethical considerations and the responsible use of these technologies into curriculum. This could ensure that the deployment of AI in investment practices upholds the integrity of the profession and safeguards stakeholder interests, preventing potential misuse and fostering a climate of trust and transparency.

It appears to me that the future of investment lies in a collaborative effort between the industry and educational institutions to develop professionals who are equally skilled in technological applications as they are in traditional investment strategies and ethics. This balanced approach could enable the investment sector to fully leverage the potential of AI and LLMs while addressing the challenges and opportunities they present, setting the stage for a new era of informed and ethical use of AI in investments.

The Integration of AI and LLMs in Modern Investment Strategies

AI and LLMs already are making significant strides in the field of investment analysis, enhancing both the efficiency and accuracy of various financial processes. Their deployment across a spectrum of activities—from risk assessment and financial forecasting to portfolio optimization and client advisory services—is proving transformative.3 For example, the advent of robo-advisers illustrates one way in which AI has the potential to increase access to investment advice. These platforms analyze an individual’s financial situation and objectives to craft personalized investment strategies, thereby showcasing AI’s ability to provide tailored financial advice on a large scale.

In the realm of quantitative trading, AI’s impact is equally profound. Investment banks and hedge funds leverage AI algorithms to sift through vast arrays of data—including market prices, news articles and social media sentiments—to inform high-frequency trading decisions.4 For example, organizations like Renaissance Technologies use advanced mathematical models to predict market movements, highlighting AI’s capacity to identify investment opportunities that may be obscure to human analysts.

Recent advancements in generative AI, particularly with models like GPT-4, have expanded AI’s capabilities in data analysis, trend prediction and scenario simulation. These models are adept at generating detailed market reports, simulating intricate investment scenarios and constructing realistic financial models based on historical data. Investment firms increasingly are experimenting with generative AI to create sophisticated trading algorithms that respond dynamically to market changes, paving the way for the future of automated trading strategies.5

Another critical AI application in investments is enhancing compliance and detecting fraud. Firms are employing AI algorithms to analyze transaction data in real time, identifying patterns indicative of fraudulent activities or compliance breaches. This not only helps protect a firm’s assets but also ensures the integrity of the financial markets.

In my view of the future, AI and LLMs are poised to play a vital role in scenario analysis and stress testing. By simulating various market conditions and economic scenarios, AI could aid investment professionals in understanding potential impacts on investment portfolios. For example, AI models are being developed to forecast how geopolitical events or sudden market shifts might affect investment returns, enabling firms to better anticipate and mitigate potential volatilities.6

The increasing incorporation of AI applications into academic curriculums, especially in finance and investment, underscores the importance of this technology. As an instructor of a FinTech class at a university, I emphasize giving students hands-on experience with AI tools for market analysis, portfolio management and risk assessment. This approach ensures that the next generation of investment professionals is not only familiar with but also adept at navigating and leveraging the technological advancements shaping the sector.

Ethical and Practical Challenges of LLMs and AI in Investments

The integration of LLMs and AI into the investment industry offers transformative potential but also introduces a host of challenges and ethical dilemmas. These challenges primarily revolve around the accuracy and reliability of the data these technologies use, the ethical implications of their deployment and the overarching need for robust regulatory frameworks.

One of the fundamental challenges in utilizing AI in investment strategies is ensuring the accuracy and reliability of the data. AI systems are only as good as the data they process; inaccuracies in input data can lead to significant errors in output. For example, AI-powered trading algorithms might misinterpret news events or social media trends, leading to inappropriate trading actions. Such incidents underscore the necessity for sophisticated filtering and verification mechanisms within AI systems to ensure that they only act on relevant and accurate information.

The use of AI in the investment sector also raises profound ethical questions, particularly concerning market fairness and the potential for manipulation. High-frequency trading algorithms, capable of executing trades in milliseconds, can dramatically influence market dynamics without human oversight. The 2010 Flash Crash exemplifies this: Rapid trades by automated systems led the Dow Jones Industrial Average to drop, wiping out billions in value within minutes before rebounding. Such events highlight the risks of overreliance on automated systems without sufficient safeguards and underscore the need for ethical considerations in AI deployment.

Another significant ethical concern is the privacy and security of client data. As investment firms increasingly turn to AI to offer personalized advice, protecting sensitive client information becomes paramount. Ensuring the confidentiality and integrity of this data is crucial, as any breach could not only lead to financial losses for clients but also erode trust in the firm and the broader financial system.

To address these challenges, it is suggested that investment firms implement robust data verification processes and work diligently to identify and mitigate any biases present in AI models. Adherence to ethical guidelines concerning data privacy, market conduct and the deployment of AI is vital.7 Additionally, regulatory bodies could play a critical role in this ecosystem, evolving to provide clear guidelines and oversight for the use of AI in the investment industry. This might include establishing standards for data use and trading practices and ensuring that technological advancements do not compromise the fairness and integrity of financial markets.

Preparing for an AI-Driven Future in Investment Strategies

The emergence of generative AI technologies has the potential to fundamentally transform the investment landscape, introducing novel content and insights derived from existing data. As these innovations continue to influence investment strategies, finance professionals and the broader industry could adopt a proactive approach to integrate these technologies into their work. Preparing for this new era involves a multifaceted strategy that includes education, ethical use of AI considerations, strategic adaptation and future regulatory compliance if and when new regulations are introduced.

In my opinion, education is the cornerstone of effectively embracing AI. Investment professionals would be well-served to grasp the fundamentals of AI and data science along with their practical applications in finance. This knowledge could enable them to understand and leverage the capabilities of AI tools effectively. Moreover, companies could invest in training programs to educate their workforce about AI, fostering an environment that encourages innovation and keeps pace with technological advancements (much of this is happening, of course). Similarly, academic institutions could revise curricula to include AI, machine learning and related ethical considerations in finance, helping graduates to be better equipped to navigate the evolving technological landscape.

The ethical use of AI is paramount in maintaining trust and integrity within the financial sector, so the investment industry could be mindful to use AI in ways that ensure fairness, transparency and accountability. This could include regular audits of AI systems to identify and correct biases, safeguarding data privacy and maintaining open communication with clients regarding how AI is used to manage their investments. Such ethical practices could help build and maintain trust among stakeholders and prevent potential misuse of technology.

Strategically, firms could reassess their current investment strategies and operational structures to identify areas where AI could add significant value. This may involve automating mundane tasks to enhance efficiency, employing AI for advanced risk management or utilizing AI-driven insights for strategic decision-making. As AI technologies evolve, firms that remain adaptable and responsive to integrating new tools could gain a competitive edge.

As AI becomes more entrenched in financial practices, the regulatory landscape may evolve to address new challenges and complexities, resulting in new regulations and legal standards for firms to stay informed about and comply with. Collaboration among industry players, academia and regulatory bodies—by sharing research and insights and developing best practices—could help create a robust framework for the effective and ethical use of AI in investments.

In conclusion, preparing for the future of AI in investments requires a comprehensive approach that balances academic education, ethical practices and strategic forethought involving AI. By embracing these elements, investment professionals and firms can not only leverage AI technologies effectively but also ensure that they remain competitive and responsible in a rapidly evolving financial landscape. This proactive preparation can help enable the industry to harness AI while navigating the associated challenges and opportunities with confidence and integrity.

Tianyang Wang, ASA, CFA, FRM, is a professor of finance in the Finance and Real Estate Department at Colorado State University. He is also a contributing editor for The Actuary.

Statements of fact and opinions expressed herein are those of the individual authors and are not necessarily those of the Society of Actuaries or the respective authors’ employers.

Copyright © 2024 by the Society of Actuaries, Chicago, Illinois.